Date: Wed, 25 May 2005 13:14:10 -0500 From: Mr Duck <tld@...eexamples.org> To: popa3d-users@...ts.openwall.com Subject: Re: popa3d that *doesn't* use syslog for logging? >>I can explain my reasons if requested (for direct file logging) > Yes, please. See below. > This has been asked for a few times (that's _just_ a few times in > several years!) and noone has provided a valid reason for this so far. > Please keep in mind that one of the design goals of popa3d is > simplicity, and that there're plenty of other POP3 servers out there. > While logging directly to a file isn't a complicated feature to add, > the combined complexity of all imaginable simple features like that is > substantial. The bottom line is that popa3d is not my baby, and what I might consider a reason enough to justify a particular features inclusion doesn't amount to a hill of beans. I fully understand your perspective. However, I like to take advantage of daemons that do direct file logging. Simply because it makes more sense to me to log everything into one file, without the need for modifications to the syslog config. This, of course, is not a difficult thing to do, but I just don't like messing with "what ain't broke" if I can help it. By using a command line switch to direct logging to a particular file, I have the benefits of: * ps shows the CL params in it's output (which tells me to where the daemon is logging) * syslog.conf doesn't have to be modified (and there is no speculation required as to what priority/facility a particular daemon is using) * no special daemon compilation needs are required (no config settings to tweak) Though, with popa3d being as simple and easy-to-use as it is, it is quite easy to know what syslog facility/priority it is using, because it's spelled out clearly in the header file. I could easily change this to a LOCAL and mod my syslog.conf and be done with it. But, I do prefer direct-to-file methods. It's just my personal preference. Anyway, I'll paraphrase a saying: "The foolish man is he who never asks."
Powered by blists - more mailing lists
Confused about mailing lists and their use? Read about mailing lists on Wikipedia and check out these guidelines on proper formatting of your messages.