Date: Tue, 26 Oct 2021 08:59:53 -0700 From: Anthony Liguori <aliguori@...zon.com> To: Solar Designer <solar@...nwall.com>, <oss-security@...ts.openwall.com> CC: Lin Horse <kylin.formalin@...il.com> Subject: RE: CVE-2021-3760: Linux kernel: Use-After-Free vulnerability of ndev->rf_conn_info object Solar Designer <solar@...nwall.com> writes: > CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you can confirm the sender and know the content is safe. > > > > On Tue, Oct 26, 2021 at 02:37:20PM +0800, Lin Horse wrote: >> 2021-09-01 Report to security and linux-distro >> 2021-09-01 CVE-2021-3760 assigned >> 2021-10-26 patch upstream >> >> Sorry for the delay of this report T.T > > Ouch. Let's use this opportunity to learn from the mishandling of this > issue and avoid that for other issues. Many things went wrong here: > > 1. The original notification by Lin to linux-distros did include "I'd > like to ask for 14 days of the embargo", which is OK'ish, but ideally > such messages should include the proposed public disclosure date/time - > and that's what the instructions ask for. When it's just "N days", I > guess people think "that's OK'ish" and move on. When it's a specific > date/time, it's easier for everyone to notice it approaching - not only > for people specifically tasked with that. That's just a psychological > detail that I guess nevertheless statistically affects the outcomes. > > So I think that the distros tasked with reviewing initial notifications > should insist on the actual date/time being present in there, or add it > on their own in an immediate follow-up. Those distros currently are > Oracle and Wind River. I'd appreciate them confirming that they accept > this clarification. > > "Promptly review new issue reports for meeting the list's requirements > and confirm receipt of the report and, when necessary, inform the > reporter of any issues with their report (e.g., obviously not actionable > by the distros) and request and/or propose any required yet missing > information (most notably, a tentative public disclosure date/time) - > primary: Oracle, backup: Wind River" > > 2. While Lin's original message to linux-distros included a "SUGGESTED > FIX" section (with a patch in it) and "I will do my best to work with > the developer on fixing this", no further messages on a fix were sent to > linux-distros. Lin, if you did in fact work with upstream on this, you > should have kept linux-distros aware of the progress, and especially of > the fix getting to public Linux kernel mailing lists or public commits, > as that ends the embargo. > > Further, distros failed to handle the corresponding "contributing back" > tasks. There was no activity by Gentoo lately at all, and while there > is recent helpful activity by Amazon, they didn't act this time. > > "Stay on top of issues to ensure progress is being made, remind others > when there's no apparent progress, as well as when the public disclosure > date for an issue is approaching and when it's finally reached (unless > the reporter beats you to it by making their mandatory posting to > oss-security first) - primary: Gentoo, backup: Amazon Yes, we totally missed this. > > Monitor relevant public channels (mailing lists, code repositories, > etc.) and inform the reporter and the list in case an issue is made > public prematurely (that is, leaks or is independently rediscovered) - > primary: Amazon, backup: SUSE > > Make sure the mandatory oss-security posting is made promptly and is > sufficiently detailed, and remind the reporter if not - primary: Gentoo, > backup: Amazon" > > I'd like replies by Gentoo and Amazon on this, please. They should > either state that they'd be handling these tasks from this point on, or > we should reassign the tasks. This is one I think we've been able to handle previously and would like to keep handling. Regards, Anthony Liguori
Powered by blists - more mailing lists
Please check out the Open Source Software Security Wiki, which is counterpart to this mailing list.
Confused about mailing lists and their use? Read about mailing lists on Wikipedia and check out these guidelines on proper formatting of your messages.