Date: Tue, 19 Apr 2011 17:11:45 -0400 (EDT) From: brad@...ystems.com To: john-users@...ts.openwall.com Subject: Re: JtR GUI ideas list <big snip> I'll snip the parts I have no input on. Hope that is OK. > Features > > There are some variants about implementation. > - GUI framework. It was decided to use either WxWidgets or Qt. Both have > some benefits. After re-visiting wxWidgets after several years away from it. I would say use wxWidgets. It's simple, handles Unicode very well and is used by a lot of companies. The license works well for JTR too (I believe). > - programming language. My first proposal was to fastly prototype gui in > Python language and then rewrite it in C++. After some debats i think > there are three usable variants: to use only C++, to prototype in > Python and then use C++, and to use only Python. They all have some > benefits. I would say go pure C++ and forget the other approaches. You can easily statically link wxWigets and build for Win, Mac and Linux. It makes distribution to end users dead simple (one executable to give them). I've used Python with wxPython as well (google Find_SSNs... I wrote that many years ago) and it uses a pure Python approach. I would not do that again today. <snip> > GUI specific optional features > - Start screen (a-la eclipse) Very easy to implement. <snip> > - i18n (i will provide english and russian languages) wxWidgets has outstanding Unicode support and great documentation to do this. I just recently integrated wxWidgets into a password generator I wrote. I call it SHA1_Pass. Source code and build scripts are on github. I was very impressed with how wxWidgets has improved over the years, the static linking has greatly improved. Binary size was impressive too. Unicode support on Win, Lin and Mac was outstanding and Solar is right, native look and feel are more important that I had initially felt they were. While I still use and like FLTK, I think pure C++ and wxWidgets is the only way to go at this point in time. Source code here: https://github.com/16s/SHA1_Pass Compiled binaries here: http://16s.us/sha1_pass/downloads/ Just my personal opinion, nothing more. I hope it helps. Brad
Powered by blists - more mailing lists
Confused about mailing lists and their use? Read about mailing lists on Wikipedia and check out these guidelines on proper formatting of your messages.