1990s: alternative authentication methods Some of these are an improvement, but they are susceptible to offline password guessing attacks on certain authentication material anyway: Challenge/response pairs What may be worse, common protocols such as POP3 APOP are poorly defined, requiring that plaintext-equivalents be stored on the server, even though this could be avoided Kerberos: TGTs, AFS user database S/Key, OPIE: skeykeys file SSH: passphrase on private key SRP: verifiers Thus, passwords (or passphrases) are not going away, and proper password hashing or key derivation remains relevant even if as a component of other authentication schemes